Best Thing I Ever Ate S2E12: Totally Unexpected

Show Best Thing I Ever Ate
Season / episode Season 2, Episode 12
Original air date Not confirmed

The 8 restaurants in this episode

Open reported A Salt & Battery New York, New York

As of September 2026, A Salt & Battery is listed open on Yelp, reviewed by our team on September 7, 2026; not yet independently confirmed through direct contact.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to A Salt & Battery after the show →
Open reported D'Angelo Bakery Santa Barbara, California

As of September 2026, D'Angelo Bread is listed open on dangelobakery.com, reviewed by our team on September 7, 2026; not yet independently confirmed through direct contact.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to D'Angelo Bakery after the show →
Open reported Evvia Estiatorio Palo Alto, California

As of September 2026, Evvia Estiatorio is listed open on Yelp, reviewed by our team on September 7, 2026; not yet independently confirmed through direct contact.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to Evvia Estiatorio after the show →
Open reported Humphry Slocombe San Francisco, California

As of September 2026, Humphry Slocombe is listed open on humphryslocombe.com, reviewed by our team on September 7, 2026; not yet independently confirmed through direct contact.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to Humphry Slocombe after the show →
Closed verified Lopez Southwestern Kitchen Cleveland Heights, Ohio

As of September 2026, Lopez Southwestern Kitchen has closed — confirmed via Yelp, June 2026.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to Lopez Southwestern Kitchen after the show →
Closed verified Relish Roswell, Georgia

As of September 2026, Relish has closed — confirmed via whatnow.com, December 31, 2010.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to Relish after the show →
Open reported The Modern New York, New York

As of September 2026, The Modern is listed open on themodernnyc.com, reviewed by our team on September 7, 2026; not yet independently confirmed through direct contact.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to The Modern after the show →
Closed verified The Monday Room New York, New York

As of September 2026, The Monday Room has closed — confirmed via Yelp, January 2026.

Last verified September 7, 2026

What happened to The Monday Room after the show →

Episode facts

Episode title: Totally Unexpected
Season: Season 2
Episode number: 12 (overall #23)
Original air date: Not confirmed
Restaurants tracked: 8 records

Episode numbering and air date compiled from public episode records including this public source . Facts only — never its wording. We publish no episode stills, artwork or logos.

Other restaurants from Season 2

Beachcomber BBQ & Grill

St Simons Island, GA

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026
Boka Restaurant

Chicago, IL

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026
Casa Adela

New York, NY

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026
Emporio Rulli

Larkspur, CA

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026
Peking Gourmet Inn

Falls Church, VA

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026
Now: Concord's Colonial Inn (formerly The Colonial Inn)

Concord, MA

Open reported Checked September 7, 2026

Share this episode

Something wrong on this page? See something wrong? Tell us →