Agnello's Pizzeria Is Now Mille Luci Pizzeria
Current status
As of September 2026, this address now operates as Mille Luci Pizzeria — confirmed via Mille Luci Pizzeria's own current website/social account, accessed March 2026. Now: Mille Luci Pizzeria (formerly Agnello's Pizzeria).
Last verified
What the source shows: Yelp (updated March 2026) and OpenTable both list Mille Luci Pizzeria as currently operating at the same 170 N Main St address, with active DoorDash ordering integration.
- Season / episode Season 1, Episode 4
- Original air date
- Address 170 N Main St, New City, NY 10956
- Current name Mille Luci Pizzeria
Interactive map — loads when you ask for it.
Everything on this map is also in the list below.
© OpenStreetMap contributors © CARTO
Note on this show: Described as staged/scripted by Wikipedia's article, citing a 2012 realityblurred.com report. Surface this note on every record.
What happened after Restaurant Stakeout?
The fourth episode of Restaurant Stakeout, "The Son and the Father," aired March 28, 2012, and covered Agnello's Brick Oven Pizzeria in New City, New York, the third of three neighboring Rockland County restaurants the show featured in close succession. The series' format uses hidden cameras to record staff behavior when no one is meant to be watching, and Willie Degel reviews that footage with the owner to identify and fix service or management gaps, in this case framed around a father-and-son ownership dynamic. Agnello's owner was not directly quoted alongside the Lexington Grille and Mt. Ivy Café owners in contemporaneous coverage of the three Rockland County episodes, but Wikipedia's article on Restaurant Stakeout describes the series generally as staged, citing a 2012 realityblurred.com report on producer-directed incidents and coached cast members at these Rockland County locations. The pizzeria's longtime address, 170 N. Main Street, now operates under a different name: Mille Luci Pizzeria, an Italian restaurant and pizzeria that appears on Yelp with an update dated March 2026 and on OpenTable with an active 2026 listing, both showing current hours and an active DoorDash ordering integration at the same storefront. Whether the change represents a straightforward rebrand, a sale, or a new lease was not confirmed within the research budget, but two independent, dated sources agree the address is active under the new name.
Featured on Restaurant Stakeout
- Show
- Restaurant Stakeout
- Original air date
- Episode title
- The Son and the Father
- What was featured
- Brick-oven pizzeria; father-and-son management problems
- Role
- Featured restaurant
- Name on the broadcast
- Agnello's Pizzeria
Frequently asked questions
Is Agnello's Pizzeria still open in 2026?
As of September 2026, this address now operates as Mille Luci Pizzeria — confirmed via Mille Luci Pizzeria's own current website/social account, accessed March 2026. Now: Mille Luci Pizzeria (formerly Agnello's Pizzeria).
What happened to Agnello's Pizzeria after Restaurant Stakeout?
The fourth episode of Restaurant Stakeout, "The Son and the Father," aired March 28, 2012, and covered Agnello's Brick Oven Pizzeria in New City, New York, the third of three neighboring Rockland County restaurants the show featured in close succession. As of September 2026, this address now operates as Mille Luci Pizzeria — confirmed via Mille Luci Pizzeria's own current website/social account, accessed March 2026. Now: Mille Luci Pizzeria (formerly Agnello's Pizzeria).
What is Agnello's Pizzeria called now?
Now: Mille Luci Pizzeria (formerly Agnello's Pizzeria). As of September 2026, this address now operates as Mille Luci Pizzeria — confirmed via Mille Luci Pizzeria's own current website/social account, accessed March 2026. Now: Mille Luci Pizzeria (formerly Agnello's Pizzeria).
Where is Agnello's Pizzeria located?
170 N Main St, New City, NY 10956. That is the address on the record as of September 7, 2026.
What season and episode of Restaurant Stakeout featured Agnello's Pizzeria?
Season 1, Episode 4 of Restaurant Stakeout, first aired March 28, 2012. The episode is titled “The Son and the Father”.
What do reviews say since Restaurant Stakeout?
The series' format uses hidden cameras to record staff behavior when no one is meant to be watching, and Willie Degel reviews that footage with the owner to identify and fix service or management gaps, in this case framed around a father-and-son ownership dynamic. We summarise what dated sources report; we do not publish our own rating.
Is Agnello's Pizzeria still using the Restaurant Stakeout menu or branding?
Whether the change represents a straightforward rebrand, a sale, or a new lease was not confirmed within the research budget, but two independent, dated sources agree the address is active under the new name. Anything newer than our last check on September 7, 2026 may not be reflected here.
Every status on this site carries a confidence label and a date, and names the source it rests on. Read the Editorial & Corrections Policy for what each label means and how quickly we act on corrections. The questions above are generated from this record's own published fields — we never publish a question we cannot answer from the data.
More from Restaurant Stakeout
-
Peekskill, NY
Closed verified Checked -
Jamaica, NY
Closed verified Checked -
New Rochelle, NY
Open verified Checked -
Anna Maria's Italian Restaurant
Larchmont, NY
Closed verified Checked -
Huntington, NY
Closed verified Checked -
Brooklyn, NY
Open reported Checked
Other TV restaurants in New York
-
Peekskill, NY
Restaurant Stakeout
Closed verified Checked -
New York, NY
Best Thing I Ever Ate
Closed verified Checked -
Jamaica, NY
Restaurant Stakeout
Closed verified Checked -
New York, NY
Best Thing I Ever Ate
Open reported Checked -
New York, NY
Best Thing I Ever Ate
Open verified Checked -
Now: S.A.B. Super Action Burger (formerly Action Burger)
Brooklyn, NY
Mystery Diners
Open verified Checked
Nearest tracked restaurants
-
Congers, NY · 2.8 mi away
Gordon Ramsay's 24 Hours to Hell and Back
Closed verified Checked -
Pomona, NY · 3.5 mi away
Restaurant Stakeout
Closed verified Checked -
Bardonia, NY · 3.6 mi away
Restaurant Stakeout
Closed verified Checked -
Sleepy Hollow, NY · 8.2 mi away
Man v. Food
Open reported Checked -
Tarrytown, NY · 8.5 mi away
Man v. Food
Closed verified Checked -
Ramsey, NJ · 9.6 mi away
Food Paradise
Open verified Checked
Visit info
- Address
- 170 N Main St, New City, NY 10956
- Venue type
- pizzeria
- Official website
- millelucipizza.com
- State hub
- TV restaurants in New York
Businesses change fast. Always confirm directly with the restaurant — call ahead, or check its own current website or social media — before making plans around anything on this page.
Sources
- realityblurred.com — https://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/2012/03/food-network-restaurant-stakeout-fake/
- Yelp — https://www.yelp.com/biz/mille-luci-new-city
- OpenTable — https://www.opentable.com/r/mille-luci-pizzeria-new-city
See something wrong?
We work hard to keep every status accurate and dated, but restaurants change fast and our sources aren't perfect. If something here is wrong — a status, a name, an address, anything — tell us what you're seeing and where you saw it, and we'll check it.
Record rs-004 · last verified .